Highland Woodworking Wood News Online, No. 171, November 2019
Book Review: Mortise & Tenon Magazine, Issue 7
Review by J. Norman Reid

As we've come to expect, the latest issue of Mortise & Tenon Magazine, the seventh in this remarkable series, is an eclectic collection of articles that probe various aspects of hand tool woodworking, craftsmanship and design. Pictorially exciting, informative, at times mind-expanding, it's a fun read. As was true of its predecessor volumes, it makes an exemplary contribution to woodworking literature that is unique in orientation.

The volume opens with an interview with a Maine handtool woodworker, Peter Lamb. A former museum curator, Lamb learned early to "make or do without," a philosophy that explains the many handmade or retooled woodworking implements he uses in his varied crafting activities. The interview explores his relationships with Bill Coperthwaite and Wille Sunqvist and his beliefs that working with his hands is more than a way of doing, but as he says of the handcraft community, "a reaffirmation of the healing power of nature."

Editor Joshua Klein next delves into an examination of David Pye's often misunderstood concept of the "workmanship of risk." A believer that diversity of work is "the tonic our souls require," Pye distinguishes between the "workmanship of risk," or mostly hand tool craftsmanship, and the "workmanship of certainty," a largely machine-based, high productivity product. But the distinction is not based on the source of power—some power tools require great dexterity and reflect the workmanship of risk. Nor is the distinction about the quality of the result, which can vary no matter the workmanship method. In the end, Pye makes another distinction, between "regulated" workmanship and "free" workmanship. The former may use jigs and fixtures to establish conformity to a pattern; the latter, by contrast, is more like a sketch in which the finished product may deviate from the original intent. Neither is inherently good or bad, nor is free workmanship a guarantee of greater quality. Rather, their meaning must be interpreted in relation to the current time and circumstances.

Bill Pavlak, a joiner in the Williamsburg Anthony Hay Shop, assesses two 18th century cabriole legs unearthed during a restoration of the shop some six decades ago. In an interesting archeological essay, Pavlak asks about the intended uses of the legs and how they happened to lie buried in the silt of a creek bed for two centuries. After speculating on these subjects, he offers observations about the methods used for their construction before attempting to execute the legs using the same techniques and making the same mistakes as the original makers did.

Michael Updegraff explores several workholding methods drawn from three traditions. Western traditions are the most familiar, and Updegraff discusses how he graduated from a bench vise to other, more workpiece-friendly methods such as planing stops and sawbenches. He contrasts these methods with those of Japanese woodworkers, in which the worker sits on the floor and works in a pull rather than a push direction. North American Native Americans employed yet another tradition, holding the workpiece with one hand while working it with the other. Updegraff concludes that we don't always need new tools for workholding and that alternatives are available if we are open to them.

Richard Arnold reports that Walter Rose, in The Village Carpenter, states that making a four-panel door was a good day's work in the mid-19th century. Arnold sets out to duplicate the feat using period tools. He estimated that in Rose's day, a good day's work was about 11 hours. Arnold finished his door in 10-1/2 hours, concluding that he had indeed done a good day's work.

One of the most enlightening articles in the volume is by Brother Arnold Hadd, who debunks some myths about Shakerism and Shaker craftsmanship. Shakers did not see themselves as craftsmen, he says, but as farmers first, using the winter months to build needed things. While they sought perfection in all they did, not all their work was perfect, and builders' skills grew as their experience developed over time. However, only the best work is shown in galleries and publications, leading to a distorted view of the whole body of Shaker work. Though Shaker pieces are often described as simple, they are often anything but so. Nor was all "Shaker" work produced by Shakers themselves, for they often hired workers to manufacture goods for sale. And, he asserts, Shakerism is not dead as is widely supposed, for there is new life in Maine's Sabbathday Lake community.

Keiran Binnie takes a look at Welsh vernacular furniture, which is designed around naturally curved limbs. Typically made by village carpenters rather than professional furnituremakers, it used a variety of woods — whatever was at hand. Though some pieces include turned parts, mostly they are shaped by hand. Binnie, drawn to a specific chair probably dating from about 1760, sets out to build one like it, and his article chronicles the challenges he faced in doing so.

A regular feature of Mortise & Tenon is a visual examination of a historic piece, this time an early 18th century high chest of drawers. Modified several times over various restorations, the piece is described in enough detail to understand its construction or to be recreated if desired.

Jarrod Dahl explores what he calls "the new wood culture," a term applied to green woodworking that pays homage to older traditions as well as new processes. He argues that green woodworking provides a direct connection to the earth and is thus a therapeutic antidote to the depression that is so often found in modern society. While he favors hand tool work, he acknowledges the value of machine tools and dried lumber for the independent woodworker to maintain profit margins. In the end he concludes that the new wood culture is best defined as the making and use of hand crafted products, rather than by a limited view of how they are made.

In an important article, George Walker contrasts the ancient view of freedom—working in the pursuit of perfection — with the modern view — freedom as flexibility of choice. He reflects on three ancient axioms of perfection in design: strength and durability; function; and beauty. The ancients argued that all three were essential to good work. But the Industrial Revolution altered the ruling axioms, first emphasizing form as following function and replacing beauty, leading to a sterility and soul-less quality in modern furniture. At the same time, the axiom of durability was replaced by one of disposability. Walker opines that though the traditional axioms have thus been displaced, internet communications offer hope for revival of the traditional axioms of good design through a community of makers.

The volume concludes with Sam DeSocio's review of Drew Langsner's 1978 classic Country Woodcraft and its impact on the green woodworking movement.

As always, beautifully photographed and laid out, this issue is a feast for the eyes and a worthy collector's item. Certainly, green woodworkers and hand tool enthusiasts will greatly appreciate the attention to their ways of working. But the volume is much more than that, and those interested in the history of woodworking and issues of design will also find much of value. Armchair woodworkers will find it a good read and a mind- stretching exercise. As always, I enjoyed devouring this issue and look forward to whatever editor Joshua Klein comes up with for his next issue.

Find out more and purchase Mortise & Tenon Magazine at Highland Woodworking.

J. Norman Reid is a woodworker, writer, and woodworking instructor living in the Blue Ridge Mountains with his wife, a woodshop full of power and hand tools and four cats who think they are cabinetmaker's assistants. He is the author of Choosing and Using Handplanes. He can be reached by email at nreid@fcc.net.

Return to Wood News Online

Click the images below to visit some of our most popular tool departments

Wood Turning 

Highland Woodworking
1045 N. Highland Ave. NE
Atlanta, Georgia 30306
Tel. 800-241-6748

Email us at email@highlandwoodworking.com
Visit us on the web at www.highlandwoodworking.com

Copyright © 2019 Highland Hardware, Inc.

Errors regarding pricing and specifications are subject to correction.
SOME SALE QUANTITIES MAY SELL OUT and become unavailable at the advertised price.