Highland Woodworking Wood News Online, No. 177, May 2020
Book Review: Mortise & Tenon Magazine, Issue 8
Review by J. Norman Reid

Once again, Joshua Klein has brought forth an interesting mix of articles expressing fresh ideas about woodworking topics in Issue 8 of Mortise & Tenon Magazine. As always, emphasis is on hand tool woodworking, with a strong sub-emphasis on living close to nature. The result is a refreshing diversion from the overwhelmingly high technology world so far divergent from the earth from which life springs. Especially now, when we are largely cut off from one another by either forced or self-imposed isolation, this issue offers welcome relief.

The lead article, by New Brunswick woodworker Harry Bryan, introduces what he calls "intermediate technology" for the woodshop. In the early 1970s, Bryan set out to live in a way that made minimal demands on the earth's resources. Inspired by Helen and Scott Nearing and later E. F. Schumacher's Small is Beautiful, he set up off the grid, without a complete wind and solar power base but rather an intermediate solution. While few of his tools—a thickness planer, tablesaw, and large bandsaw—are powered by his solar cells, more of his tools are human powered using treadles, hand cranks, and even a 10 speed bicycle mechanism that drives one of his band saws. Hand tools make up the rest of his equipment. His belief is that advanced society doesn't know when enough is enough. His intermediate solution between electric power work and human-powered tools is his attempt to attain a balance that doesn't exceed "enough."

Joshua Klein's article "Showing What is Possible" recounts the visit by an international team of hand tool woodworkers to build a timbered blacksmith shop near his woodshop. Organized by the French-based Charpentiers Sans Frontières (Carpenters Without Borders), the team built a 16 x 25' blacksmith shop on Klein's property. Not only did they raise the structure, but they taught each other new ways of working large timbers—the Europeans teaching the North Americans, and the North Americans returning the favor.

The article describes the procedures the team followed in building the structure. But the real lesson was in the camaraderie that was shared and in learning that there is no one right way to do the work.

In what I thought was one of the most delightful articles in the issue, Cameron Turner, a high school English teacher, relates how he introduced woodworking into his American literature courses. In a course that ordinarily teaches the writings of the likes of Emerson and Thoreau, Turner's three classes of 11th grade girls were given an opportunity to build a replica of the desk on which Thoreau wrote Walden and his famous essay on civil disobedience. Given no grades on their shop project, the girls took to it eagerly and quickly learned new skills and experienced the joy of discovery. Turner reports that this novel approach helped the students to feel more empowered and to develop a greater appreciation of beauty and for the value of work.

An interview with Roy Underhill, the self-styled Subversive Woodwright, follows. The interview explores Roy's career development and his approach to making his fabled TV program so successful. Now he's focused on teaching, something he loves to do. His current venture, the Woodwright's School, started off slow but now demand exceeds the supply of classroom spaces, since his offerings are a part of the "experience economy." His biggest regret is that he doesn't get more African-American students, in whom he'd like to rekindle the spirit of such outstanding practitioners as John Hemmings and Thomas Day.

Amy Umbrel, a carver of spoons and other utensils, shares her experience of finding a place for herself in the world of crafting. Her belief is that it's important for her to be tied to the spirit of the natural environment around her and that her work uses local natural materials rather than wood imported from elsewhere. Her gentle essay offers a calming antidote to the hectic search to find meaning in an otherwise chaotic world.

Each issue of Mortise & Tenon contains an examination of a period piece, its details and construction. In this issue, the piece is a grain-painted chest-over-drawer dating from the late 18th to early 19th century. The piece, built of pine, is thoroughly documented with both dimensions and ample photographs.

One of the most fascinating articles in the issue is Dr. Mike Epworth's tale of the legend of the Jimmy Possum chair. The chairs are traditional to the southernmost island of Tasmania, a part of Australia. Legend has it that the design originated with one Jimmy Possum, said to have lived in the hollow of a large tree. But who was Jimmy Possum? Was he an Irish famine refugee, a resettled English convict, or a member of the First Nation, Australia's aborigines? Or did he never exist all? Epworth reports on his attempt to discover the truth about Jimmy Possum and the chairs that emanated from his tradition.

The chairs resemble Irish hedge chairs in basic design but differ in fundamental ways. Unlike any other chairs, the legs extend through the seat to terminate in the chair's arms. The shape of the legs is such that the seat is wedged in place by the leg taper. The market for original chairs attributed to Jimmy Possum and other early makers at one time drove prices as high as $80,000. But copying, theft, and fakes eventually drove the market down. Epworth started making his own version of Jimmy Possum chairs several decades ago, eventually converting from a machine shop to a backpack toolkit like Jimmy Possum would have used that enables him to do his chair work anywhere he chooses.

Michael Updegraff explores the methods by which one can attempt to discern the history of older pieces. Given the sparsity of printed guides to woodworking techniques in earlier times, how can we recover those techniques so they can be applied efficiently today to craft the kind of quality furniture that emanated from those fabled workshops? A variety of documentation can be researched, including published works where they exist, ledgers, tax and estate records, journals and diaries, as well as surviving tools, shops, and of course examples of the furniture itself. For the latter, reading the tool marks can be a valuable source of information about the methods employed, and Updegraff lays out a series of methods that can be applied to this task. The article is supplemented by a field guide to tool marks that offers, with illustrations, helpful tips on what to look for.

Next follows an essay drawn from Joseph Park's early 20th century book on manual training. His argument, quite relevant to today, is that training in the manual arts is important for child development. Not only does it foster physical development, but he argues that it helps develop aesthetic tastes, engages intellect, builds character, and of course, teaches concrete skills that can be applied throughout life.

This issue concludes with a review of Aldren Watson's excellent book, Hand Tools: Their Ways and Workings, an encyclopedic guide to hand tools that's beautifully illustrated by the author's hand drawings.

As is customary for Mortise & Tenon Magazine, this issue is richly illustrated with color photographs and, where helpful, drawings and supplementary tables, making it a feast for the eyes as well as for the mind.

There have been so many fascinating issues of Mortise & Tenon since it originated that it's impossible for me to place this one within the ranks of the others. Frankly, it's a darn good issue, easily the equal of the others if not their better. It's a welcome read that's as easy on the mind as it is on the eyes. If you've liked the preceding issues, you're sure to love this one.

Find out more and purchase Mortise & Tenon Magazine
at Highland Woodworking

J. Norman Reid is a woodworker, writer, and woodworking instructor living in the Blue Ridge Mountains with his wife, a woodshop full of power and hand tools and four cats who think they are cabinetmaker's assistants. He is the author of Choosing and Using Handplanes. He can be reached by email at nreid@fcc.net.

Return to Wood News Online

Click the images below to visit some of our most popular tool departments

Wood Turning 

Highland Woodworking
1045 N. Highland Ave. NE
Atlanta, Georgia 30306
Tel. 800-241-6748

Email us at email@highlandwoodworking.com
Visit us on the web at www.highlandwoodworking.com

Copyright © 2019 Highland Hardware, Inc.

Errors regarding pricing and specifications are subject to correction.
SOME SALE QUANTITIES MAY SELL OUT and become unavailable at the advertised price.