Highland Woodworking
 
The Workshop Book by Scott Landis
Review by J. Norman Reid

Scott Landis, the author of The Workbench Book I recently reviewed, has written a parallel volume on workshops titled The Workshop Book. Like his book on workbenches, this book reports on the results of a broad survey of workshops throughout North America. The result: a comprehensive review of workshops in practice, their design and features, that will be a valuable source of information and guidance for any woodworker setting out to build a new workshop or refashion or upgrade an existing one. Like The Workbench Book, this book reports on site visits to a wide range of workshops and details the ways in which their design and equipping suits the type of woodworking each conducts. In consequence, Landis is able to convey practical experience as opposed to theoretical principles to inform woodworkers' choices in the design of their own shops.

The first decision a woodworker encounters in planning a workshop is where it should be located. The most common location for home woodworkers is the basement. This choice has the advantage of being close at hand and using other potentially vacant space. But it comes with some downsides, including the likelihood of concrete walls and a lack of natural light. Garage workshops, also popular, have similar benefits to basement workshops but face the probability of lack of water, limited electric power, and poorer heat and humidity control.

Landis reviews other configurations as alternatives that will be options some woodworkers can consider. These include devoting a room in the home to woodworking, using the whole house or one floor, a freestanding building, repurposing an industrial building, and setting up a storefront workshop. Each of these options has its benefits and downsides, which are laid bare in Landis's conversations with the owners of these types of shop.

Once the location has been decided, the next set of decisions concern the shop's layout. Landis underscores a key principle to observe in laying out any shop: to maintain as much flexibility as possible to allow for future adjustments and changes, both temporary and permanent.

Among the arrangements Landis observed and documented are Kelly Mehler's division of his workspace into zones for different kinds of operation, an organization Landis terms "triangle" grouping in which complementary tools and fixtures are co-located. Another arrangement is to set up dedicated spaces for specific functions — spray booths, offices, showrooms, and sharpening stations are examples. Some shops are shared with multiple woodworkers; these may combine common spaces for shared equipment with individual workspaces for each woodworker.

Landis describes other scenarios that may work for woodworkers with greater space restrictions. A minimalist shop might have fewer machines or be a hand tool focused shop to save space. Other shops — like this writer's — might be what Landis calls "eclectic," combining several functions such as photography, metalworking, ceramics, and other parallel creative activities. He also shows some woodshops that are set up in cars and other vehicles.

Equipping the shop is the next consideration. The issue here, he says, is not what machinery you own but how it fits into your woodworking practice. His advice: start with the machines that will do the most grunt work. And he repeats Tage Frid's caution not to buy cheap or underpowered tools. Landis offers some advice of his own about table saw selection, though it should be noted that he wrote before the SawStop went into production.

Although most woodworkers will choose to purchase their tools new or used, some have made a practice of rebuilding older equipment and in some cases making it themselves in the shop. As you tour workshops with Landis, you'll meet several woodworkers who've made good use of this tactic and get the benefit of their experience.

Other possibilities are human-powered shops in which such tools as lathes, drills, jointers, and shapers, among others, are pedal powered. And, as a foretaste of what was to become, Landis points to computer-driven workshops, though his observations were penned in a pre-CNC and laser engraving day and thus lack the latest developments in this area.

Encompassing other issues in setting up a workshop are what Landis terms "systems." Often neglected in favor of tool selection, these are critically important backgrounds for effective shop work. Systems, as he describes them, include structural elements such as insulation, doors, floors, and walls; electricity; dust collection; lighting; heat and humidity control; compressed air; fire and shop security; and plumbing. As he does throughout the book, Landis delves into each element with a critical assessment of the issues and options as informed by the experiences of those he interviewed.

In a chapter devoted to specialty workshops, Landis notes that shops work best when they are designed to fit the functions of the work performed in them. He observes several such shops, including two chairmaking shops that employ just the tools needed to get their work done. Other cases he encounters are farm workshops, rolling workshops such as a pickup truck and a van, and workshops set up for use by kids.

No shop will ever be perfect, of course, but Landis encounters some he regards as dream workshops, and he portrays them in plenty of detail to inspire other woodworkers to plan their own workshops for the future.

Storage is a problem in always-too-small shops. Tools, hardware, and wood all need to have a convenient home in a shop. Landis shows several tool chests and toolboxes, for which he includes plans that can be replicated. In addition, he surveys methods for hanging tools on the walls and various means for storing lumber.

The final chapter addresses shop fixtures, which can help shops to function efficiently and safely. Among the fixtures he reviews are sharpening stations, benches, horses, auxiliary machine tables, workstations for portable tools, and safety accessories. He provides plans for several fixtures, including a basic workbench, a veneer press, a router table, and table saw sleds.

This book's primary value is the opportunity it offers to survey a wide range of workshop solutions through the eyes of woodworkers who have adopted them. A study of this wealth of information is guaranteed to better inform the choices a woodworker will make in setting up his or her own shop. There is no right answer to shop design and each implementation will be unique. The experiences in this book will help woodworkers to find a best fit for their own work and help ensure that shop time is effective and safe.

This book has one other historical benefit. Landis points to the nearly complete lack of information about how woodworking was organized and conducted in times past. He cites what little we know. This volume fills the contemporary void by describing the diversity of woodworking practices in the late 20th and early 21st centuries. As such, it will have historical value well into the future.

Because it was originally published in 1991, it is out of date concerning some recent developments, such as LED lighting, CNC machines, and finger saving features in tools. But these omissions are slight in view of the overwhelming timeliness of the design, organization, and equipping issues all woodworkers must confront in setting up shop. The result is a volume of high and continuing relevance.

Hardbound and slip covered, this book is filled with photos and illustrations that make Landis's descriptions come to life. Like all Lost Art Press books, it is a quality production that will last a long time even under heavy and repeated consultation.

This is an excellent resource for any woodworker setting out to create a new shop, whether for the first time or as an upgrade. It's an encyclopedic source of ideas drawn from the practical experience of those who've tried each alternative. And it's a fun opportunity to step inside a wide range of shops and look over the shoulders of other woodworkers as they go about their business. For these reasons, it will make a valuable addition to many woodworking libraries.

Find out more and purchase The Workshop Book
at Highland Woodworking


J. Norman Reid is a woodworker, writer, photographer and woodworking instructor living in Virginia's Blue Ridge Mountains with his wife, a woodshop full of power and hand tools and two cats who think they are cabinetmaker's assistants. He is the author of Choosing and Using Handplanes: All You Need to Know to Get Started Planing by Hand, and co-owner of Shenandoah Tool Works. He can be reached by email at jnreid45@gmail.com.

Return to Wood News Online

Click the images below to visit some of our most popular tool departments







Finishing
 
Books
 
  Clearance
 
Festool
 
Planes
 
Sharpening
 
Wood Turning 
 
MONTHLY NEWSLETTER
ARCHIVE
SUBSCRIBE TO
OUR NEWSLETTER
    WATCH HIGHLAND'S FREE
    ONLINE TV SHOW
VISIT HIGHLAND'S FULL
ONLINE TOOL CATALOG

Highland Woodworking
1045 N. Highland Ave. NE
Atlanta, Georgia 30306
Tel. 800-241-6748

Email us at email@highlandwoodworking.com
Visit us on the web at www.highlandwoodworking.com


Copyright © 2021 Highland Hardware, Inc.

Errors regarding pricing and specifications are subject to correction.
SOME SALE QUANTITIES MAY SELL OUT and become unavailable at the advertised price.